|
The DHA/EPA Difference
- ** It is well documented that DHA rich
fatty acids are required for proper larval development. Fish oils may exhibit higher EPA
levels than ALGAMAC, however, through the process of retroconversion, most marine organisms can
produce sufficient levels of EPA from DHA. Conversely, many types of marine animals are
incapable of elongating EPA into DHA resulting in a DHA deficient diet unless
supplementing with a DHA rich formula
Back to top
Importance
of PUFA/HUFA Function and Other Trace Elements in Marine Organisms (Finfish /
Shrimp)
A Brief Synopsis of the Affects
and Benefits of the Fatty Acid: DHA
The requirement for 22:6n-3 (DHA)
fatty acids in marine fish and shrimp nutrition has been established by
Kanazawa, Watanabe and others via feeding diets both rich and deficient in these
lipids. The exact mechanism for this requirement is well documented for fish and
vertebrate animals but less so for shrimp. The most likely answer may be in the
postulate that biological membranes (cells) rich in di-22:6 (n-3)
phosphoglycerides have a phase structure that is relatively constant in the face
of changing environmental variables such as temperature, pressure and salinity
and also a normal and unchanging bilayer width. These considerations rest
heavily on the facts that the double bonds in naturally occurring PUFA/HUFA are
methylene-interrupted in the cis orientation and that the more double
bonds there are in a fatty acid, the more the fatty acid is structured by these
double bonds. This effect reaches a maximum in 22:6 (n-3).
 | This generates the favored minimum-energy
conformational "angle iron" form of the molecule. It would account
for the highly beneficial effect on stress tested shrimp containing high
levels of this 22:6 (n-3). |
 | A second requirement for PUFA/HUFA and 22:6
(n-3) can be found in the vitellogenic process and precursors for the
enzymatic and hormonal processes within the shrimp. |
 | Production of ecdysone for molting, growth and
egg production require highly mobile and flexible energy sources as found in
PUFA/HUFA. |
Fish phosphoglycerides generally
contain about 50% of their total fatty acids as n-3 PUFA/HUFA with a ratio of
22:6 (n-3) : 20:5 (n-3) of about 2:1. This is seen most clearly in the
phosphoglycerides of fish eggs.
Back to top
The lipids of diatoms contain
large quantities of 20:5 (n-3) with appreciable quantities of C16 (n-3)
PUFA/HUFA but negligible amounts of 22:6 (n-3), whereas the lipids of
dino-flagellates contain large amounts of 22:6 (n-3) and also 18:5 (n-3).
 | Most hatcheries do not culture high PUFA/HUFA
species of micro-algae to supply 22:6 n-3 sources to the larvae and thus the
origin of substitution PUFA/HUFA to the diet of shrimp (and other marine
eukaryotes) with commercial products containing high levels of these lipids. |
Innumerous comparisons of
oil-based enrichments vs. whole cell preparations of AlgaMac (Schizochytrium
sp.) have shown that not all of the pigmentation and eye spot development of
larval fish could be attributed to fatty acid composition of the larvae.
 | Whole cell preparations of AlgaMac supply a
broader profile of nutrients such as carotenoids, sterols, phosolipids and
vitamins than oil-based enrichment products and may account for this
observation. |
Back to top

WHAT
IS DHA?
Technical Explanation:
Dososahexaenoic acid (DHA), 22:6(n-3) is one of the
longest chain HUFA's in the n-3 and n-6 series of fatty acids. DHA along with
DPA and EPA are long chain fatty acids essential for the normal development of
larval fish and shrimp (Watanabe
et al. 1978) and also oyster spat (Langdon
and Waldock (1981), Ostrowski and Divakaran (1990), Watanabe (1993), and
Ozkizilcik and Chu (1994). Aquaculturists derive these
fatty acids mostly from fish oils (ie: Menhaden or Squid -Ika- oil) offered by
many manufacturers. Though these oils do contain DHA, it is at very low,
undetectable levels. They are mainly rich in EPA (eicosapentaenoic acid,
20:5n-3) which is also essential but not the only HUFA necessary. The main
concern is most animals inability to elongate EPA into DHA. Studies
suggest that most animals have the capability to retroconvert DHA into
EPA but not the other way around. Therefore, an EPA rich oil will still leave
your animals DHA deficient. This also includes enrichment of rotifers and
Artemia prior to feeding your animals. (See: Nutritional
Enhancement of n-3 and n-6 Fatty Acids in Rotifers and Artemia Nauplii by
Feeding spray-dried Schizochytrium sp., William Barclay, OmegaTech Inc.,
& Sam Zeller, NutraSweet Kelco Co.)
WHAT IS EPA & DPA?
Eicosapentaenoic acid (EPA), 20:5n-3 and docosapentaenoic
acid (DPA), 22:5(n-6), are also in the category of longest chain HUFA's in the
n-3 and n-6 series of fatty acids. These long chain HUFA's are integral, through
biosynthesis, to early nervous system development of fish and shrimp. The n-6
HUFA, including arachidonic acid (20:4n-6)
is also important as the precursor of some prosta-glandins
and other biologically active compounds which regulate growth and reproductive
functions (Stanley-Samuelson 1987; De Petrocellis and Di Marzo 1994). Napolitano
et al. (1988). Tests suggest further that the n-6 fatty acid may be critical for
normal marine bivalve development and reproduction (Napolitano et al. -1988).
Again, the focus is on the ability of marine animals to retroconvert DHA
into EPA/DPA and its inability to elongate EPA/DPA into DHA.
- High DHA emulsions/oils vs:
AlgaMac-3000
- High DHA emulsions/oils may be DHA rich but
like any oil, have a shelf life. Over time, the integrity of the oil will
diminish and ultimately go rancid. Also, oils compromise the water quality.
They are difficult to mix into the water (especially cold water), and much
it ends up being wasted.
-
- With AlgaMac-3000,
you get a clean, hygeinically safe dry powder that readily mixes in water
and will last on the shelf.
Back to top
|
|