|
PARTIAL REPLACEMENT OF LIVE ALGAE IN THE LARVICULTURE OF Penaeus
vannamei WITH MICROENCAPSULATES AND SPRAY-DRIED ALGAE Schizochytrium sp.
-
- P. Boeing
- Pacific Seafarms International S.A. de C.V., Cerro Escondido #122, Lomas
de Mazatlan, Mazatlan, Sinaloa, Mexico.
Introduction
Although the successful total replacement of live algae in the
larviculture of penaeid shrimp has been reported (Ottogalli, 1991), there still remains
the need to produce sufficient amounts of live algae for the average hatchery to produce
good quality seed for most penaeid species. The routine production of this live algae is
expensive, labour intensive and can be unpredictable. This study was designed to
investigate how the amounts of live algae required can be reduced throughout the larval
stages without affecting survival and metamorphic rate to the postlarval (PL) stage in Penaeus
vannamei.
Back to top
Materials and Methods
Three experiments were carried out, the first was designed to establish
if partial replacement of live algae with spray-dried heterotrophically grown Schizochytrium
sp. was possible. The second experiment was designed to further reduce the amount of live
algae required by using a single dose of live algae (SDLA) fed at the first feeding stage
and then no more, only combinations of the dry diets. The third experiment was
designed to test the Schizochytrium sp. at 100% replacement after the larvae had
received the SDLA.
All experiments were conducted in 2 l round bottomed flasks containing
larvae stocked at the zoea one stage (Z1) at a density of 100/l in triplicate. The
seawater was filtered to 5 mm
and was not changed during the experiment, salinity was 32 parts per thousand and the
culture temperature was maintained at 28 ± 0.5 C by means of a water bath. Gentle aeration was provided through a fine bore
(2 mm internal diameter) glass tube at the bottom of each flask. Previous experiments
provided the optimum daily ration for the dry diets to be 6 mg/l/d for both CAR (INVE
feeds) and MicroMac-30 (Aquafauna Bio-Marine) and 8 mg/l/d for Schizochytrium sp.
(AlgaMac-2000, Aquafauna Bio-Marine) or at their relative percentage substitutions. The
diets were re-hydrated into suspension using a glass homogeniser just prior to each feeding
time, and supplied to the larvae in four equal doses per day up to Mysis one (M1). All
treatments received freshly hatched Artemia nauplii at 5/ml from M1 to PL1.
The larvae were counted upon reaching PL1 to assess the percentage
survival and sub samples from each triplicate were measured for total length.
A comparison of the average survival rates and total length measurements
between the live fed controls and the dry diet replacements was carried out for each
experiment using ANOVA, results were considered significant at the P < 0.05 probability
level.
Back to top
Results and Discussion
The results from experiment one summarized in table 1. show that the
percentage survival, metamorphic rates and total length measurements between the controls
fed 50,000 cells/ml Chaetoceros sp. and a feeding regime of 25,000 cells/ml
Chaetoceros sp. + 4mg/l/d AlgaMac was not significantly different P<0.05. The
results also show that the larvae fed on 50,000 cells/ml Tetraselmis suecica or a
mixture of 25,000 cells/ml Chaetoceros sp. and 25,000 cells/ml T. suecica
were not able to survive, suggesting that the larvae at Z1 can not ingest the larger cell
size of T.suecica or if it is ingested that it may not be digested. Hence
demonstrating that a ration of 25,000 cells/ml Chaetoceros sp. alone is not
sufficient to produce growth if not co-fed with the AlgaMac-2000.
Back to top
Table 1. Average survival rates, metamorphic
rates and total length measurements reached by the first postlarval stage in experiment
one.
- Feeding regime
- from Z1 to M1
|
Average survival rates from
Z1 to PL1 (%) |
Time (days) from Z1 to PL1 |
Average total length (mm) |
Chaetoceros sp.
50,000 cells/ml |
61a |
11a |
4.59a |
Chaetoceros sp.
25,000 cells/ml
+ AlgaMac 4mg/l/d |
71a |
11a |
4.74a |
Chaetoceros sp.
25,000 cells/ml +
T. suecica 25,000 cells/ml |
0 |
n/a |
n/a |
T. suecica
50,000 cells/ml |
0 |
n/a |
n/a |
- n/a: not available
- Values with the same superscript in the same column are not
significantly different (P<0.05).
The results from experiment two summarized in table 2. show that there
is no significant difference between the live fed controls and both of the treatments for
either survival or metamorphic rate, but there was a significant difference in the total
length. Both of the treatments given the SDLA followed by either of the microencapsulated
diets in combination with the AlgaMac-2000 at 75%,25% levels respectively, were both
significantly larger than the live fed controls.
Back to top
Table 2. Average survival rates, metamorphic rates and total length
measurements reached by the first postlarval stage in experiment two.
- Feeding regime
- from Z1 to M1
|
Average survival rates from
Z1 to PL1 (%) |
Time (days) from Z1 to PL1 |
Average total length (mm) |
Chaetoceros sp.
50,000 cells/ml + T.suecica 20,000 cells/ml |
77a |
10a |
4.21a |
SDLA + CAR 75% +
25% |
78a |
10a |
4.76b |
SDLA +
MicroMac-30 S 75% +
- AlgaMac
25%
|
- 86a
|
- 10a
|
- 4.82b
|
-
- Values with the same superscript in the same column are not
significantly different (P<0.05).
Back to top
The results from experiment three summarized in table 3. show that there
was no significant difference between the average survival rates, metamorphic rates and
total length between the live fed controls and the treatment of SDLA + 8mg/l/d AlgaMac-2000.
Table 3. Average survival rates, metamorphic rates and total length
measurements reached by the first postlarval stage in experiment three.
- Feeding regime
- from Z1 to M1
|
Average survival rates from
Z1 to PL1 (%) |
Time (days) from Z1 to PL1 |
Average total length (mm) |
Chaetoceros sp.
50,000 cells/ml + T.suecica 20,000 cells/ml |
94a |
11a |
4.75a |
SDLA +
- AlgaMac
8mg/l/d
|
- 97a
|
- 11a
|
- 4.80a
|
-
- Values with the same superscript in the same column are not
significantly different (P<0.05)
Back to top
Conclusions
The results of this study strongly suggest that the larviculture of P.
vannamei from Z1 to PL1 is possible using only a minimal amount of micro algae fed to
the first feeding stage, with subsequent and regular feeds of either well formulated
microencapsulated diets or the spray-dried marine micro algae Schizochytrium sp..
Moreover, the addition of the SDLA to the culture medium may provide a beneficial
bacterial population which assists in the use of the aforementioned dry diets and reduces
the amounts of water exchange required (Freeman et al., 1996). The condition of very early
postlarvae is often difficult to assess, but recent work by (Barclay and Zeller, 1996) has
shown the docosahexaenoic acid (DHA) and eicosapentaenoic (EPA) rich Schizochytrium
sp. was successfully used for the enrichment of Artemia nauplii with these highly
unsaturated fatty acids. This suggests that the continued feeding of Schizochytrium sp.
throughout the stages of penaeid development receiving Artemia nauplii, would
enhance the nutritional value of the Artemia to the shrimp. It has been pointed out
that resistance to stress is related to the presence of adequate levels of DHA and EPA in
crustacean larvae (Dhert et al., 1992). This is in agreement with recent findings
(Montań o and Navarro, 1996) that wild post
larvae contain higher levels of both DHA and EPA, and are in turn more resistant to
handling stress, resulting in higher survival when introduced to the on-growing ponds.
Back to top
References
Barclay W., S. Zeller. 1996. Nutritional enhancement of n-3 and n-6
fatty acids in rotifers and Artemia nauplii by feeding spray-dried Schizochytrium
sp. J. World Aqua. Soc. vol 27 no3 p314-322
Dhert P., P. Lavens, and P. Sorgeloos. 1992. Stress evaluation: a tool
for quality control of hatchery produced shrimp and fish fry. Aquacult. Sci. 17:6-10
Freeman M., N. Misciattelli, Z. Che Cob, C.A. Martinez Palacios, A.O.
Alab, and D.A. Jones. 1996. Preliminary trials demonstrating the effects of culture water
conditioning on the use of microencapsulated diets in penaeid larval culture. (In press)
Tercer Symposium Internacional de Nutricion Acuicola. 11 al 13 Noviembre de 1996
Monterrey, Nuevo Leon, Mexico.
Montań o
M., J.C. Navarro. 1996. Fatty acids of wild and cultured Peneaus vannamei larvae from
Ecuador. Aquaculture 142:259-268.
Ottogali L. 1991. Complete substitution of microcapsules for algae for
P.stylirostris larval rearing in New Caledonia. J. World Aqua. Soc. 22:46A
Back to top
|
|